Commerce clause essay

Amesand the regulation of prostitution in Hoke v. Swift and Stafford v. The power to govern interstate navigation, for example, was justified under the clause in a case, Gibbons v.

Through time, the clause has been changed to restrict federal power. By the time of the industrial revolution in the late nineteenth century and into the early twentieth century, the reach of the commerce power was again called into question.

It is not yet clear whether a similar restriction will be applied to Congressional regulation of all non-economic, noncommercial activities see Morrison at p. If the scheme generally regulates a commercial activity, the Court may be willing to characterize all of the applications of the statute as the regulation of commercial activity even those that reach activity, which viewed in isolation, might Commerce clause essay considered noncommercial such as the medicinal marijuana grown for personal consumption in Raich which was regulated as part of a comprehensive regulation of the illegal drug market.

Commerce clause essay the term is not clearly defined, there has been much debate over its exact meaning and consequently, the extent over which trades, exchange, and even commercial and social interactions between people from different states can be regulated and controlled by the federal government.

Marshall found that Congress had the authority to regulate navigation between states pursuant to its commerce power, and the federal license trumped attempts by states to regulate in the same waters. This test shows great deference to the judgment of Congress, a judgment often, but not necessarily, reflected in Congressional findings, hearings and committee reports.

Filburn and Gonzales v. The Court initially struck down numerous statutes involving labor and other economic policies that it considered purely local activities outside the purview of the commerce clause.

Filburn, Heart of Atlanta and Perezthe test the court uses is whether Congress could have rationally concluded that the regulated activity has a substantial economic effect on interstate commerce. Article I, Section 8, of the U. It ruled that because some business, even though done entirely at a local level, could eventually contribute to interstate commerce in the movement of product and services.

This enabled Congress to bring price fixing to an end in the Chicago meat industry. The fact that Congress may have been motivated in whole or in part by a moral objective is not relevant so long as the regulated activity also has a substantial economic effect on interstate commerce as in the case of the Civil Rights Act of when Congress outlawed racial discrimination in places of public accommodation both because of the immorality of discrimination and also because the discrimination had a negative effect on interstate commerce by discouraging travel by African-Americans.

Constitution lists the powers of the U. Nonetheless, the exact scope of the commerce clause has long been a subject of debate and even controversy.

When regulating interstate commerce itself, the Congressional motive is irrelevant even if the regulation is designed to achieve non-economic objectives such as to promote morality as in the Lottery Case.

United Statesand Katzenbach v. The University of Chicago Press, The American Supreme Court.

Commerce Clause Essay

As a result, one questions whether or not the federal courts would or ever have abused this clause. Constitutional Deliberation in Congress: When Congress regulates an interstate economic activity or enterprise under a comprehensive regulatory scheme, it may also regulate the aspects of that activity that are intrastate in character as in Wickard v.

Wallacethe shipment of lottery tickets in Champion v.Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution, the Indian Commerce Clause states that: The Congress shall have power to regulate Commerce with foreign.

Research Paper: Commerce Clause Found in the U.S. Constitution under Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3, the Commerce Clause essentially gives Congress the authority “to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among.

Essay Exclusion Clause exempt himself from the liability by the exclusion clause written on the receipt and the sign. The effectiveness of. The commerce clause states that Congress has the power to tax, monitoring international trade with other nations, and interstate trade with other states.

2. The Necessary and Proper Clause is located in Article I, Section 8, clause This is an essay about the Commerce among the States in the Constitution. Article I, Section 8, Clause 3: Commerce among the States The Heritage Guide to.

The Regulation of states by the commerce Clause as a source of Congress Power (Essay Sample) Instructions: The Commerce Clause is the source of much of Congress’ power to regulate the states.

Commerce clause essay
Rated 5/5 based on 71 review